of the Review Process
It is our editorial goal to complete the first review cycle
within three months after you receive the paper. Excessively
long review cycles are a problem: the author is obviously unhappy
and is discouraged (and my discourage others) from submitting
to the Transactions in the future. Long delays also
result in our published papers being less timely and ultimately
of less interest to our readers. Thus, it is important to keep
the review cycle as short as possible.
To ensure a short review cycle, the following plan is recommended.
- Carefully select referees and request reviews within one
- The reviewer should agree to decline to review the paper
within two (2) weeks. If you do not hear form the reviewer
after one (1) week, an automatic email is sent to the reviewer.
- The review should be completed within five to six weeks.
Automatic reminders are sent out at 3, 45, and 60 days.
- Occasionally you will encounter a referee who still will
not respond. In this case, a personal phone call followed
by a personalized email may help. For example, you can write
the following: "In fairness to the author, I must soon
make a publication decision and I would like your review
in order to make that decision. That will also save me from
going out for further reviews, which will delay the review
process. Please send in your review by <date>."
Note that the referees who do not respond within a two-month
period (and who may consequently force you to go for an additional
review) may result in an additional two months being added to
the review process. Thus, it is particularly important that
you choose your initial set of referees carefully and that you
keep up with the review process.
When the reviewer completes the review, the tool thanks the
reviewer. Also, later in the process, each reviewer is automatically
notified of the decision and is given a copy of all reviewer
score sheets (the parts intended for the authors).
The Transactions on Vehicular Technology are published by the IEEE and sponsored by VTS
To contact the editorial office, email System Administrator or Editor-in-Chief
or send correspondence to:
Professor Michael Fang, Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering, University of Florida, 435 New Engineering Building, P.O.Box 116130, Gainesville, FL 32611, USA.
Modified: April 2013